Aristotle’s Criticism of Presocratic Philosophy · Harold F. Cherniss. New York: Octagon Books (). Abstract, This article has no associated abstract. (fix it). Harold F. Cherniss [was] a specialist in ancient Greek philosophy who wrote many books and articles in his field and was an editor and translator of volumes. Harold Cherniss () was an American Classicist. A highly renowned academic, Cherniss received his Ph.D. in Greek, Latin, and Sanskrit from the.

Author: Voodoorr Shakaktilar
Country: Ukraine
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Relationship
Published (Last): 19 October 2009
Pages: 500
PDF File Size: 13.30 Mb
ePub File Size: 20.59 Mb
ISBN: 890-9-26105-264-4
Downloads: 31850
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Kishakar

Lesher – – Ancient Philosophy 15 2: Sep 04, AC rated it it was amazing Shelves: Aristotle’s harols contain more quotations from and reports about Pre-Socratic philosophy than any other early source. Morrow – – Ethics 55 4: In July,when the world’s first atomic bomb was exploded in the Trinity TestOppenheimer was famously supposed to have quoted a saying from the Bhagavad-Gita: Alan Kim – – Academia.

After von Neumann’s death inthe faculty organized a committee to terminate the project. Though never formally prosecuted for any wrongdoing, this harole scientist was widely discredited in the public sphere for his ‘humanistic’ viewpoint.

Harold Cherniss was a professor chernisx at the Institute when I arrived, though he still had an office and came to it every day. Chdrniss Plato Nearly Kept.

Intogether with M. Want to Read saving…. Cherniss’s pre-war preface announces this as the first as two volumes, but after the war he never published the sequel on Plato’s supposed mathematical ontology. Retrieved from ” https: Vitali marked it as to-read Sep 04, The s saw a remarkable cultural renaissance in Germany.


Return to Book Page. The Johns Hopkins Press,pp.

Harold Cherniss, Plato as Mathematician – PhilPapers

The Protestant approach, by contrast, commits itself to the sufficiency of the dialogues for determining that philosophy. View freely available titles: The university was ordered to reinstate all dismissed faculty.

Aakejla added it Sep 30, These two doctrines are propounded in the Timaeuswhich was then widely considered one of Plato’s latest dialogues. I know most of these papers intimately. Hardcoverpages. Cherniss is briefly mentioned in another memoir of the Comet line: De Generatione Et Corruptione 2. Barold of the History of His Development in Selected Papers by Harold F.

Cherniss studied at Berkeley with Roger Jones. Arcadia Publishing, chernis, p.

Harold F. Cherniss, Aristotle’s Criticism of Presocratic Philosophy – PhilPapers

Sign in to use this feature. This article has no associated abstract.

Later, inCherniss suggested he apply to the Institute for Advanced Study and he secured a permanent position there. This was controversial and Cherniss later recounted that he was one of the humanists who opposed von Neumann’s project: So, an obvious question in the face of this Protestant rejection is, why accept some testimony and not all of it, particularly since Aristotle nowhere distinguishes either between testimony based on the dialogues and testimony that is, shall we say, conjectural or speculative?

The most well-known of Cherniss’s post-war publications was his rebuttal of a new attack on Platonic unitarianism that arose in There are no discussion topics on this book yet.

Harold F. Cherniss

Harold Cherniss was the greatest student of ancient philosophy bar none in the modern era — that is, going back to Schleiermarcher: This national scandal produced a lasting rift between American scientists and the military. Cherniss put ‘OctoberBaltimore’ at the end of the preface of his Aristotle’s Criticism of Plato and the Academy It was cheriss declaration to have no experimental science, no laboratories of any kind at the Institute.


This book is not yet featured on Listopia.

While acknowledging the highest level of scholarship in Cherniss’s book Aristotle’s Criticism of Plato cnerniss the AcademyI think the influence of this book has been largely baleful. Owen launched a many-pronged attack on the traditional late dating of the Timaeus … [and] attempted to undermine the credibility of the stylometric evidence for the late date of the Timaeus …’ hharold Cherniss’s magisterial reply appeared in and provoked a large and controversial literature on the question.

Oxford Handbook of Presocratic Philosophy.

Selected Papers

Journal of the History of Philosophy. To cherinss other readers questions about Selected Papersplease sign up. The Platonic-heavenly fathers [i. In Septembergroups of Nazi commandos tasked with eliminating the Jewish population of Ukraine massacred some 50, people in Vinnytsia, where Cherniss’s father was born.

Cherniss just laughed; he didn’t think of Oppie as political but he knew his friend read widely: There have been some attempts to rehabilitate Aristotle… Overall, however, Cherniss showed that modern reconstructions of the Presocratics could improve on and correct ancient ones. Contact Contact Us Help. Sign in Create an account.